Seeing Brum as others see us

I have just read this article by Matthew Parris, the former MP and distinguished columnist, which was written during the recent Tory Party Conference.

A significant chunk of those attending seem to have avoided Brum for the best part of 20 years or so. The main thrust of the article is that most of the conference was pleasantly surprised to find that Brum is a really nice city and that Brummies are really friendly. Mr Parris also contrasts "the light and space and the indefinable modesty of Birmingham" with Manchester's "snivelling swagger".

The comments on the article make interesting reading, with a number of disgruntled Mancunians raising strong objections and a number of other people suggesting that this is just another example of a London-centric journo patronising the provinces.

I will leave it to Manchester to defend its own honour - my main point is to disagree with those Brummies who feel patronised. Although I can understand where they are coming from, I think the article is good news. What's wrong with a (admittedly London-based) high-profile journalist who hasn't been to our city in ages forming a great impression of the place and telling the rest of the country about it?

Ever since I've moved here, I have received "jokey" comments from friends and family about Brum. And let's face it, if your main impressions of the city are formed by the views from either Spaghetti Junction or New Street Station, you're unlikely to have a positive opinion. I would suggest that the challenge for our civic leaders is to ensure that, on his next visit, Mr Parris can't help but comment even more favourably. At least he didn't compare us (in contrast to Manchester) to a "celestial public lavatory" from which I can only assume that he didn't park his car in one of our less than salubrious city centre car parks.