http://blogs.birminghampost.net/business/

The Tories brought us a pound sign and lots of noughts. But is that the best measure to use?

By Mik Barton on Oct 3, 08 09:08 PM in

So how much was it all worth to Birmingham? I'm talking about the Conservative Party Conference of course.

It reminds me of a fairy tale.

Once upon a time a city staged a big race around the streets. In many ways it was a great success, but there was a problem with the weather - so when they counted the spectators, this tale is of what might have happened if someone added a few to make the figures look good?

(We had a related issue with our gas meter reading recently, where the man who came accidentally wrote down an 8 instead of a 6 in the tens of thousands column. Once that was in the British Gas computer it took ages to convince them that the current reading really is less than last winter's figure and, no, our direct debit should not go up by 210 per cent thank you very much.)

I digress. Back to the imaginary motor race...

Let us pretend that the following year the event had grown, it was better than the previous year and perhaps the attendance was really quite good. But even though they could have told everyone this real figure, it was less than last year's announcement - and everyone could see there were more spectators for the second year. So instead, perhaps they might have taken the previous year's 'figure' and added a bit. And so it went on for many years.....

Over on the Post's Lifestyle blog Jon Bounds has been commenting on the figures for the Conservative Party Conference in Birmingham. He makes the interesting point that " the Tories brought £20M to Brum .... The Rotarians are also estimated to bring £20M despite there being twice as many of them, well I suppose they do drink less," he said.

His piece is well worth a read - it's one of those spot-on blogs that has many serious points among the humour.

Now you've read it, let me expand his analogy of Birmingham as giant licensed premises with Mike "global boozer, local barstool" Whitby as landlord.

One benefit Jon has overlooked is the number of people who buy property near the bar or restaurant (Moseley Village for example) because it's a lively, cool place to live - but they never actually drink there?

It works the same for museums and theatres as well. How many people love the fact that Birmingham has such a great cultural offering, but never taste it themselves?

Whether you visit them or not, conferences and other big events are important in getting cities noticed. A few weeks ago I wrote about bumping into some foreign delegates and the impression of Birmingham they would be taking home with them.

Whenever it has hosted a big conference or a world championship sporting event Birmingham has all too often fallen into the trap of trying to quantify its success on the international stage. It is declared a success simply because so many thousands of people visited or took part. Quantity, not quality, has been given precedence in the promotional argument that biggest is generally best.

The idea of taking delegate numbers, multiplying by the average cost of a hotel room and adding the bar bill is about as useful as calculating 'equivalent advertising value' in the PR industry. It makes interesting reading, it tells us something - but it is not the whole picture.

That's why a party conference is important: because it brings important people to Birmingham.

We often say that the city suffers from outdated perceptions and that once people visit they change their view. I certainly experienced a lot of that among journalists and others visiting during the European Capital of Culture bid.

Sometimes it is important to communicate the scale of an event, but let's not get too hung up on figures.

We can have thousands of Rotarians drinking in our bars, a group of politicians who (one day) might decide the country's future or one solitary visitor who comes quietly, unannounced, goes to a concert at Symphony Hall, then gets out his cheque book to relocate a multi-million pound business here. We should welcome them all.

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: The Tories brought us a pound sign and lots of noughts. But is that the best measure to use?.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.birminghampost.net/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/33450

1 Comments

Jon Bounds said:

Thanks Mik, I think you've got to the point where I was heading — I got a bit distracted with thoughts of scratchings and skol white top.

I guess the thing is yes, welcome everyone and it's great to have top class events facilities, but it's not something that politicians should expect gratitude from the locals for.

And the bare (-faced lies?) financial figures mean absolutely nothing.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Business authors

Alun Thorne

Alun Thorne - The Birmingham Post's Head of Business
My postings |Alun Thorne's RSS feed My feed

Guy Bloom

Guy Bloom - Birmingham-based executive coach
My postings |Guy Bloom's RSS feed My feed

Carol Barrie

Carol Barrie - Tax Partner at RSM Bentley Jennison in Birmingham and Head of the Property & Construction Group for the UK
My postings |Carol Barrie's RSS feed My feed

David Harte

David Harte - Digital Central project manager at Birmingham City University
My postings |David Harte's RSS feed My feed

Mohammed M-Hasan

Muhammad M-Hasan - Managing consultant
My postings | Mohammed Hasan's RSS feed My feed

Ruth Ward

Ruth Ward - Independent PR Consultant and Director of Creative Republic
My postings | Ruth Ward's RSS feed My feed

Mik Barton

Mik Barton - Head of PR company Actuality Media
My postings | Mik Barton's RSS feed My feed

David Bailey

David Bailey - Professor of Economic Policy and International Business, University of Birmingham
My postings | David Bailey's RSS feed My feed

Nick Lockey

Nick Lockey - New Media Producer, Maverick Television
My postings | Nick Lockey's RSS feed My feed

Sam Smith

Sam Smith - Head of content development for Freestyle Interactive
My postings | Sam Smith's RSS feed My feed

Stuart Pemble

Stuart Pemble - Construction Lawyer, Mills & Reeve
My postings | Stuart Pemble's RSS feed My feed

John Cranage

John Cranage - The Birmingham Post's automotive correspondent
My postings | John Cranage's RSS feed My feed

John Newbold

John Newbold - Co-owner of Birmingham creative company 383 Project
My postings | John Newbold's RSS feed My feed

Latest Birmingham Post Lifestyle blog

Lifestyle Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from the midlands give you the lowdown on what's happening in your region and some musings on culture in the UK and beyond.

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links