http://blogs.birminghampost.net/lifestyle/

Who is pulling mac strings?

By Sid Langley on Mar 29, 08 10:48 AM in Culture

*To see the news story generated by this post click here.
strings.jpg

A storm in a teacup (or perhaps a tiny mug, as will become clear), but I feel that my rather pretentious "cultural commentator" tag gives me licence to open up a bit of a debate.

Tomorrow (that's Sunday, March 30 as I write this) at the mac there's an auction of hundreds of puppets which have been hidden away in a basement for 15 years. I've previewed it in an earlier blog and the Post has done the same in good old fashioned newsprint.


I can't make the sale because of grandfatherly obligations, which, obviously, have precedence over any journalistic considerations, but the Langleys are planning to be at the Cannon Hill Park venue for its final weekend (April 5 and 6). Report to follow.

It's being billed as a Puppet Extravanganza, a title which guaranteed our attendance. In previous years there have been brilliant weekends under this branding at the mac. Last year it extended to the Dynamics festival which took in venues all over the region.

I now hand over to Clive Chandler, puppeteer extraordinaire and director of PuppetLink, to make some points which are worth talking about particularly as the mac closes down for 18 months for its big facelift. What does the future hold? Rather than let Clive pull my hack strings, I'll let him have his say. Over to you, Clive:

When is an Extravaganza not an Extravaganza? Answer: when it does not involve the skills of PuppetLink in programming, when it is organised by mac on its own, when it has so little money spent on it that it only features a single show (and a workshop). In conversation with mac several months ago they mentioned that they were planning on including puppets but when we asked what budget they had we realised that nothing of any note could be done.

We had no idea that would go on to appropriate the name Puppet Extravaganza and apply it to an event that cannot possibly deliver on the expectations that the name implies. PuppetLink is officially 'furious' that mac has simply stolen the title.

The Extravaganza has been built up over the years up by PuppetLink using money that it has raised from Arts Council. Mac's contribution has been the venue. Unfortunately PuppetLink was not in a position to fund an event this year. It is an act of arrogance for mac to think it can do on a shoestring what PuppetLink has achieved with real passion and proper funding.

PuppetLink has been very proud of creating an event in which lots of things happen all over the building, both inside and out and particularly in our ability to bring work of the highest quality both from this country and overseas. We have no problem with the show that mac have booked this year, indeed it is a show that we have booked for the event in the past. Equally we have regularly used the artist who is delivering the workshop - but one show and one workshop does not make an Extravaganza.

What we have here is a triumph of spin over substance which is coming to characterise what is happening at mac. If you believe their own publicity machine you would think that Birmingham is about to get an exciting new arts centre.

However, a cursory glance at the plans on display make it very plain that what they are doing is building new a new cafe and administration block. There is still after all these years of talking about it to be no new theatre. Yes, the building needs to be stabilised and made watertight and yes it needs better access and lifts, but what a shame that in real terms the level of artistic facilities is not to be improved.

I see there will be more exhibition space and better conference facilities but is that really what the city needs? We have not progressed from the 1960s in the sense that the theatre spaces remain on the drawing board for a future phase. Mac can never flourish until it builds artistic spaces and has real artists working in them.

It seems odd to spend 13 million on a shiny new four wheel drive to tow a 40-year-old caravan.

The partnership with the Sampad is to be admired and has clearly been a useful lever to gain funding, but whatever happened to Cannon Hill Puppet Company, Maestro Steel band, Stage Two Youth theatre and many other groups that once lived and breathed at mac?

What we need from mac is an arts centre with artists and their work at the centre. We need facilities and a vision that can win back the dwindling audiences. Calling this year's event an Extravaganza will be an insult to the artists who have worked so hard to build it up, and also to their audience who they have developed with such care. Most of all it is an insult to common sense.

In the middle of all this spin and marketing nonsense is there a little boy in the crowd somewhere who is prepared to point out that the emperor is really naked....?

Right, Clive has had his say and your "cultural commentator" is back. I must say we love the mac and personally and professionally I back what they're doing and will continue that support.

But there are some good points here. Let's, as Mrs Merton used to say, have a heated debate.

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Who is pulling mac strings?. TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.birminghampost.net/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/921

3 Comments

Martin Jones said:

I feel the strength of MAC was always its resident groups such as John Blundall's Puppet Theatre, the Maestro's Steel Band, the Youth Theatre and its Theatre in Education groups.

These groups gave it permanence, providing sources of knowledge and expertise for countless others to draw upon and obtain advice, support and inspiration.

In 1983 when Hip Hop culture crossed the Atlantic from New York City and swept through the UK's cities, I was a youth worker in inner city Hockley and I approached MAC for rehearsal space for the first breakdance crew in the city, the Ace Squad.

MAC's dance coordinator Alan Dilly invited us to give a workshop to his regular dance class. He was happy to welcome our dancers and we were asked us to run workshops for Hip Hop enthusiasts on Sunday afternoons in return for rehearsal space in their dance studios.

This led to a whirlwind two years, when over 100 young people each week from all over Birmingham's inner city found a regular home where they could explore their creativity and develop their talent.

As one of the crew told me recently: “The impression that MAC gave out of “The Arts� was a million miles away from what kids in Handsworth, Hockley or Ladywood were doing but the Hip Hop dance sessions on Sunday afternoons helped to break down that exclusivity.�

Being based at MAC, we met plenty of talented people such as Alan Heap, who ran Taking Steps comedy duo,and later appeared in Michael Crawford’s Barnum in the West End, and Adrian Lester who starred in the BBC’s Hustle series.

Alan went to the Birmingham Athletic Institute (BAI) for training in tumbling for his comic routines and at his suggestion, I arranged for all the group to go to the BAI for training to add variety to their performances.

The workshops culminated in a tremendous celebration of Hip Hop talent at an event called "Thriller in the Park" in 1984 - the UK's first ever Hip Hop Festival.

The resident crew at the Puppet Theatre helped us build and decorate a "Thriller" set for the event and through contact with formally trained dancers at the centre we developed our act into a stage performance.

The start given us by MAC led to my groups turning professional and travelling all over the world, and one individual - drum and bass star Goldie - becoming internationally famous.

I'll never forget the help the MAC gave us. I just hope that the £13.6m will be spent wisely and that the centre always retains its policy of keeping an open door and approachable image for young people in the city - it's as badly needed now as it was 25 years ago.

Mac The Cat said:

These muppets running mac at the moment are giving us puppets a bad name!

Clive Chandler said:

The comments I made to Sid which he reported on this blog, got taken up as a front page article in The Birmingham Post on Monday. They were billed as an 'attack'. Actually like many other people I have been a huge supporter of what mac has done over its 40 year history. I worked in the Puppet Company for a time and have also presented a production of Jack and The Beanstalk in collaboration with their new work and productions department. I have directed two big puppet festivals and lots of little ones that mac has supported. Only this weekend I worked collaboratively with Mac to find appropriate closure on the disputed issue of the puppet collection. In that front page article my comments were dismissed as 'ill informed', but how well informed to you have to be to see that the current plans on display at mac do not include the 500 seater theatre that at the time of Birmingham's bid to be City of Culture was a much trumpeted cornerstone of our pitch and apparently an essential part of the regeneration plans for mac at that time. Successive managers, including those presently in post have bravely sought to complete the task which was begun in the 60s. My arguement is exactly the same as theirs has been. They need proper artistic spaces, including a proper theatre in order to flourish. The current display at mac of historic plans for rebuilding provides all the information needed to reach that simple conclusion. Our City has failed to give the venue that key element for forty years and whatever good things Arts Council and the City council are doing now, that really important good thing is not one of them - once again. I am also well informed enough to know that there is promise of jam tomorrow, but events move quickly in a city like ours and there are other strong contenders in the running for that prize. By pointing out that that real trophy is yet to be grasped by mac, those of us who support our arts centre hope to ensure that its frustrated managers will eventually get the crucial last piece of the puzzle, which despite their best efforts seems to have been lost down the back of the sofa for a very long time.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Lifestyle authors

Richard McComb

Richard McComb - Restaurant critic and columnist for The Birmingham Post
My postings | Richard McComb's RSS feed My feed

Jon Bounds

Jon Bounds - Digital consultant and creator of Birmingham: It's Not Shit
My postings | Jon Bounds's RSS feed My feed

Selina Jervis

Selina Jervis - Student and creator of fashion blog, "Flying Saucer"
My postings | Selina Jervis's RSS feed My feed

Pete Ashton

Pete Ashton - Pro-Blogger and creator of the “Created in Birmingham� blog
My postings | Pete Ashton's RSS feed My feed

Nikki Aaron

Nikki Aaron - English language teacher uncovering life in Beijing
My postings | Nikki Aaron's RSS feed My feed

brumcast

Brumcast Lite - A taste of the best of Birmingham's music scene by Brumcast creator Little Chris
My postings |Brumcast Lite's RSS feed My feed

Sarah Gee

Sarah Gee - Young professional and founder of Indigo PR
My postings | Sarah Gee's RSS feed My feed

Jo Ind

Jo Ind - Features writer and columnist for The Birmingham Post
My postings | TJo Ind's RSS feed My feed

Andrew Cowen

Andrew Cowen - Features writer and columnist for The Birmingham Post
My postings | Andrew Cowen's RSS feed My feed

Sid Langley

Sid Langley - Freelance writer and cultural commentator
My postings | Sid Langley's RSS feed My feed

Michael Mclean

Michael Mclean - Cinema manager at Birmingham Odeon
My postings | Michael Mclean's RSS feed My feed

Pint Sized

Pint Sized - Searching the best ale in the West Midlands
My postings | Pint Sized's RSS feed My feed

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links