Who wants social mobility?
It's been a good week for social mobility. We have been seeing the rural village in Kogelo, Kenya from which Barack Obama's family comes.
And the Cabinet Office has published a report which shows family background has slightly less impact on GCSE results for those born in 1990 than those born in 1970.
Hooray, we officially say. But are we really cheering?
There is nothing like having a baby for the hidden snob within to come out of the cupboard and pole-dance shamelessly around the post-natal classes.
A group of professional women will be eating cakes, showing off their toddlers and discussing whether their progeny are watching too much TV.
"It's OK to let them watch a bit," the group will agree. "It's the ones that dump them in front of telly on all day and never read to them that have got the problem."
Whether the subject was cooking meals or having swimming lessons, I found the group, in the nicest possible way, would find solace in being better than those of a lower social class.
I was always taken aback by this, not least because one of the many thing I enjoyed about being a mother was feeling solidarity with women from different social backgrounds.
I felt very moved in hospital, on the bus, in the baby clinic to notice that whatever our class and culture, us mums were all feeling that same tiger-like love towards our young.
We would look each other in the eye and smile in what I experienced as warm recognition.
It was only in the exclusively middle class gatherings that the civilised hostility came to the fore.
Given that, I wonder how much most well-educated people on good incomes really want the divide between the rich and the poor to narrow.
Do those with something to lose really want justice and social equality or do such things fade into ignorable grey concepts in the face of the red-blooded urge for their own kids to stay ahead?
Older/Newer
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Who wants social mobility?. TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.birminghampost.net/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/91308




















Why do you think there's all this nonsense about school admissions, moving house, suddenly going to church etc? Middle class = condescension and snobbery and tiger-like defence of what's 'their's' against all-comers. It's another way of saying Tory, the natural state of motherhood.
PS: Congratulations on getting your blog posted - the site hasn't been functioning properly since the latest 'upgrade'
I've lost a few postings in the upgrade too....
Thanks for the comment. Yes, this is another take on the whole school admissions business. I guess I was taken aback because it started as soon as our babies were latching on.
You've never seen middle hostility until you've been to a Boden clearance sale. It's an utter nightmare!
Thanks for the warning Jayne! I'll steer clear...