Reduce tourist visas to stop unwelcome foreign relatives
Hello everybody, and welcome to my blog!
Firstly, introductions: I'm Roshan Doug - a columnist on The Birmingham Post. For a number of years, as a freelancer, I've been writing feature articles - mainly on arts and politics - for this and a few other publications both here and abroad. Recently - and sporadically - I have also written and presented a handful of documentary features for BBC Radio 4.
I am delighted to announce that as from today, I'm going to be writing my posts regularly - once a day at least - on various topical issues. I hope that the style and perspective of these will entice you to take part in some of the discussions on this platform. In regard to topics, well, they'll be determined by whatever happens to be in the news - regionally, nationally and internationally.
As for my point of view, generally speaking - I'm not partisan to party politics. I'm very much apolitical. But, of course, that's not to say I'm not political. I am - deeply. It's just that my own politics is made up - not by any specific ideological leaning - but by a concern to keep things within reason.
So let's see how we get on...
Now I don't know about you but I was interested to learn last week that the government's proposing to tighten up immigration laws relating to citizenship, visas and, the introduction of English language testing. It reminded me of an experience a close friend of mine had a couple of years ago.
He was getting married and, in the true spirit of celebration invited a close relative over from Punjab, India. He sent him an invitation and a sponsorship form and, within a few weeks, his Indian uncle had obtained a visa from the British High Commission in New Delhi - just like that.
Surprisingly, however, he missed the wedding and arrived rather nonchalantly, instead, a few days later. Was he taking the mick? Well, it certainly didn't please my friend given that the whole premise of his coming over was the wedding itself. But, he found out that his uncle had other ideas in mind.
Within a couple of weeks, my friend told me, he started becoming restless and began asking for someone - such as my friend - to take him out and show him the wonderful sights of our country. My friend did as much as he could, spending his own money in London, Manchester, Stratford-upon-Avon, the Lake District and north Wales, but obviously there's a limit to hospitality. There is, after all, only so much you can do especially if you're working five days a week and in need of time to yourself as well - not forgetting that he and his wife were still in a honeymoon period.
So soon my friend had to say diplomatically, 'I'm sorry but I can't keep taking you around ever weekend because we can't afford it' (hint, hint). His uncle took offence at this and said contemptuously, 'Well, then get me a job so that I can earn some money of my own.' My friend thought he was pulling his leg. But he wasn't.
Now, bearing in mind that anyone who comes over on a tourist visa cannot work here legally, the option they take - especially when they don't speak a word of English - is to seek illegal work in an Asian sweatshop or a local grocery store where it's not uncommon to find legal (or illegal) visitors.
Anyway, my friend declined and explained that it's illegal and that he too would be breaking the law if he helped him seek illegal employment. His uncle took offence at this and decided to live with another relation of his in Middlesex - one who presumably wouldn't be so unaccommodating to his illegal wishes.
Or so he thought.
Almost a year later my friend spoke to the relation who offered his uncle the alternative shelter. This man told him how difficult it was to look after someone - providing him with food and a roof over his head - for six months. He said, the uncle had told him that my friend had kicked him out - which clearly wasn't the case. Even the relation realised this. He said he gave him so many hints to go back to India but he just wouldn't take notice.
Apparently - and this is very surprising - six months is the minimum period for a tourist visa. Why, the relation asked, are tourists given such a long period of stay in this country? Living with visitors from abroad with whom you have very little in common - apart from a vague ancestry - is a nightmare. Getting them to go back is almost impossible. He said it's like a prison sentence or living in the Big Brother house with a guest from hell.
So you can imagine how flabbergasted he was when the uncle suggested at the end of the six months period - and in all seriousness - to extend his stay of entry. As if, thought the relation, packing his bags and ordering the taxi.
Now this might sound shocking but it's quite typical as a scenario and might be familiar with other British Asians. And it doesn't just apply to ordinary visitors looking for an opportunity to make some money whether it's by working here (as in the case of my friend's uncle) or - if they're young enough - by getting married to someone of a British national.
It might equally apply to 'spiritual' guides such as the one my cousin invited over, a seemingly humble Sikh pundit. After six torturous months of looking after since April last year - and when it was time for him to leave - he suddenly came up with a story that he was being persecuted in India for being a Sikh. He wanted to apply for asylum. My cousin was shocked by his startling cock-and-bull testimony of which even he, as his disciple, could not swallow for a second. So he refused to help him with his asylum application only to find that the following day, the guru did a runner.
Even to this day, after more than five months since his disappearance, my cousin has no idea of where he suddenly vanished. I joked that but perhaps the Police should start checking up on sweatshops and grocery stores. Yes, he agreed. Unless, of course, he's hitched up with an Asian woman of a certain age and applied for a British passport. Then it's anyone's guess as to whose proverbial leg he's pulling...
Older/Newer
« Tales from a House of Commons lobby journalist | West Midland transport offers more questions than answers »



















Many visitors to the UK come to see family and friends and are more than happy to go back to their own country after six months and many in my own experience have returned before their visa expired. As with everything there will always be exceptions to the rule. The new proposals to tighten laws relating to citizenship and English language testing is welcomed but will also cause numerous problems for the older generations who have lived in this country and made it their second home but do not have enough command of the English language to pass a test to qualify for citizenship. Interesting comments Roshan.
Deena, thank you for your comments. I accept that many people to the UK come and go without a problem, but you must agree that there are some people who do try and take advantage of their entry and will do their utmost to find whatever means at their disposal to stay here - legally or (as in many cases) illegally. Language testing is slightly a different matter to visas, me thinks.
Yes Mr Doug, I agree that there are people who do stay here illegally after being granted a visitor visa and I welcome the proposal to make it difficult for such people to stay in the UK.
You mentioned the introduction of English language testing in your comments and I just thought I would voice an opinion. To me it seems very fimiliar to the way US citizenship is granted. There are many who cannot apply for citizenship in the US due to a language barrier and as a result do not qualify for benefits - I can see the same thing happening in the UK some time in the future.
I must agree that people to UK do take advantage of our system, but we must be careful that we don't fall into the hands of people with a racist agenda. Niice piece. Thanks.
Hi Roshan,
I loved your comments on the BBC current The Passion. Balanced, fair and sensitive.
I've been a Christian for 16 years and everytime I revisit this story it's moves me afresh...and grows in significance.
You overlook one thing....it's all true! I'm so pleased that you enjoy the story.
Have a happy Easter.
Janet >
Thanks for your kind words, Janet. Have a look at my post about Good Friday... You might be able to illuminate a thing or two!
Beware that the pleasure of kicking the ladder you used to climb may be short lived. Hope you had time to read Yesmin Alibhai Brown's piece in today's Independent.
Roshan, I'm sorry but I can't agree with you. As a British Asian, I have only seen my family in India twice. That does not mean we only have ancestry in common as I am extremely close to them. With the current system, it absolutely frustrates me having to send every detail of my life from bank statements, payslips,a copy of every page of my passport, a letter from my employer, phone bills, utility bills, mortgage documents, etc to the Government just to allow them to visit once in their lifetime, when we Brits are obsessed with visiting the Taj Mahal and Goa and expect to be welcomed with opened arms. And yes all my family members speak perfect English. I really don't think your friend's story is as common as you think.
Yasmin Alibhai-Brown was absolutely right in her assessment of you in todays Independent, Roshan.
Although being an immigrant your self you seem to have a fair and unbiased opinion, which I find refreshingly true.