http://blogs.birminghampost.net/news/

The system and 'diminished responsibility'

By Roshan Doug on May 8, 08 09:21 AM in Crime

The story concerning Josef Fritzl - who has now admitted holding his daughter, Elisabeth, captive in the cellar of the family home for 24 years and repeatedly raping her - has clearly shocked the entire world. The heinous nature of his crime - his inhumanity to his own flesh and blood - defies belief.

But what has transpired now is that, through his lawyers, Fritzl is arguing that at least he didn't kill her and their children.

In other words, we as a civilized world should be grateful for small mercies. At least he didn't kill.

It's really bizarre.

And so - as often happens in such horrific cases that are robbed of sense, logic or reason - his lawyers are going to put the case for diminished responsibility, that he's not, and never has been, mentally balanced.

This doesn't sit comfortably with me. I think someone - or something -
should be held responsible for what's happened to the unfortunate victims such as, perhaps, the inadequate, insufficient checks and balances. Who's responsible for that?

Apparenly, Fritzl was convicted of rape in 1967 and was sentenced to a term in prison. However, under Austrian law, unless the crime carries a life sentence, a conviction must be removed after no more than 15 years.

And so Fritzl was officially allowed to become responsible for the care of three of the seven children he fathered with Elisabeth, adopting one child and fostering two more.

It's all to do with lack of checks - and I think social services and the system as a whole should be accountable.

As for his madness, I don't know.

But the way he carried out his monstrous act, cleverly hiding the facts from all concerned and manipulating the system and the authorities, seems to suggest someone far from mentally disturbed.

This is the working of a very astute, very intelligent man.

For 24 years he, alone - apparently - made a complete fool of the system.

Forgive me, but it's not he who needs to have his head checked - but the authorities and the system which our great and the good have put into place.

Even in our own country, we, like Elizabeth and her children, are the victims of the system that enables serious foreign criminals - terrorists and murders - to work in our airports without having proper checks.

So although a retired woman who wants to work as a lolly-pop lady for a near-by school will, by law, have to go through a rigorous CRB check, foreigners can work close to international aeroplanes parked at airside without any one making a slightest enquiry to authenticate their backgrounds.

And they wonder why terrorists are having a field-day.

I ask you, who's mad - monsters like Fritzl and international terrorists who can mastermind mass destruction or, us for allowing our leaders to display such startling indifference and neglect for our safety?

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: The system and 'diminished responsibility'. TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.birminghampost.net/cgi-bin/mtcs4/mt-tb.cgi/4710

6 Comments

Gwen Henry said:

Don't rights and responsibilities come into play here. The 'criminals' have rights under all kinds of legislation, but 'we' conveniently forget / ignore responsibilities.

garry said:

Roshan, I love you're rants, they have an air of authenticity - please don't water them down like you've done in this piece. It's good, balanced, cool - but flippin' boring!!.. I mean, so what??? Blogs should be exciting to read like you stuff about sodding Muslims!

Amandeep said:

Hi roshan.. like you blogs. -
I think fritzl should be forced to live the way he treated his daughter and children! 'Hope he rots in hell!

And this stuff about foreign workers - are you having us on? that can't be true - can it? I haven't read anything about it...

Rebecca said:

It was in the news a couple of days ago cause i heard something. I'm sure i did... Roshan? i read your piece in The Sunday Times about death/funeral - on the web. it was very moving.

Roshan Doug said:

Thanks for that, Rebecca - nice of you to say so.

Robert Downton said:

Hello Roshan,

It's me Robert from Halesowen College.Just to say I find your articles refreshing.I like the authenticity you put into your views they make for a good read.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

News authors

The Big Debate

The Big Debate - Start the debate. Digital: More Power or Powerless? June 9 at the ICC. Postings | The Big Debate RSS feed Feed

Simon Hadley

Simon Hadley - The Birmingham Post's picture editor
My postings | Simon Hadley's RSS feed My feed

Paul Dale

Paul Dale - The Birmingham Post's public affairs editor
My postings | Paul Dale's RSS feed My feed

Phil Davis

Phil Davis - Board member of Passenger Focus (rail transport passenger group)
My postings | Phil Davis's RSS feed My feed

James Treadwell

James Treadwell - Criminologist, Birmingham City University
My postings | James Treadwell's RSS feed My feed

Stef Lewandowski

Stef Lewandowski - Owner of digital design agency 3Form and part of Birmingham's Big City Plan
My postings | Stef Lewandowski's RSS feed My feed

Marc Reeves

Marc Reeves - Editor of The Birmingham Post
My postings | Marc Reeves's RSS feed My feed

Emma Brady

Emma Brady - The Birmingham Post's health correspondent
My postings | Emma Brady's RSS feed My feed

Shahid Naqvi

Shahid Naqvi - The Birmingham Post's education correspondent
My postings | Shahid Naqvi's RSS feed My feed

Jonathan Walker

Jonathan Walker - The Birmingham Post's political editor
My postings | Jonathan Walker's RSS feed My feed

Roshan Doug

Roshan Doug - Writer and political commentator
My postings | Roshan Doug's RSS feed My feed

Picture Archive

Picture Archive - A selection of historical pictures from Birmingham City Council's Picture Archive.
My postings | Picture Archive's RSS feed My feed

Tom Scotney

Tom Scotney - The Birmingham Post news reporter
My postings | Picture Archive's RSS feed My feed

Latest Birmingham Post Business blog

Latest Birmingham Post Lifestyle blog

Lifestyle Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from the midlands give you the lowdown on what's happening in your region and some musings on culture in the UK and beyond.

Latest Birmingham Post Sport blog

News Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from Birmingham and the midlands inform and entertain on all sporting matters.

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links