http://blogs.birminghampost.net/news/

NHS? It's not what it used to be!

By Roshan Doug on Jul 3, 08 08:04 AM in

Since every other article/news item is about the NHS' 60th anniversary, perhaps I can share a related anecdote.

My mother, like many other elderly people, suffers from arthritic pain in her knees and relies on knee-support bandages. On one occasion her existing bandages had worn out and the pain had become unbearable. Our GP referred her to the A&E because it was difficult for her to stand without assistance.

So on our arrival at the local hospital, I went in search of a wheel-chair. Now, you'd think there'd be plenty of wheel-chairs especially in the A&E, wouldn't you?

But oh, how wrong you'd be.

Initially, I saw three or four wheel-chairs chained to the wall. In my naïve wisdom, I enquired with a couple of nurses and a receptionist if they could release one, but they just looked at me as if I were asking for a kidney. 'Those are purely for emergencies', they informed me.

So annoyed and exasperated, I took up my search up and down the corridors - but to no avail.

Not even crutches or a walking stick were in sight.

Two security guards and a hospital porter couldn't locate a wheel-chair either. One of them even stated - and I'm not kidding - that the chances of finding one free are pretty low. 'You're mother would be better off walking slowly.'

I was flabbergasted and wanted to punch him on the nose. Surely we were in a hospital in the UK, weren't we - not in the Sahara or the paddy-fields in India?

I can't work out why it is that all the unhelpful people or nutters end up working for the council or the NHS?

Nevertheless, I did eventually find one - half an hour later - by which time I was fairly annoyed. But the ordeal didn't stop.

Once we got through the prolonged boredom of waiting in the A&E, my mother was expected to change in the x-ray room without privacy in front of a male radiographer. It was as if he thought a woman of a certain age loses her right to privacy and respect. Obviously we complained and it was only reluctantly that he provided her with a cubicle.

It's clear that older people in this country are not given the same kind of consideration and courtesy afforded to younger patients. The overwhelming presence of some staff nurses talking loudly patronisingly about/to patients, so that everyone in the hospital can hear, does little to improve matters.

And there's blatant incompetence.

A few weeks previously my mother went to see a young nurse at our surgery, at our GPs referral, for those bandages as support for her knees (they have to measure the legs, apparently). But the girl - sorry, nurse - had no idea why we were there. Nothing in her notes gave her any hints. So we explained what was needed and remember - my mother's in pain. The nurse stated that she couldn't measure her legs because she wasn't a district nurse. That's the job of her other colleague who was on holiday. Could we come back next week, she asked.

Could we heck! I wanted to strangle her slowly.

But I stayed calm.

I explained that we were disappointed and requested a visit from the district nurse. That, we were told, might take some time because they're very busy and understaffed.

That was rather absurd because two weeks, two district nurses (not one) came over to hand my mother... a Zimmer frame, not support bandages.

My mother explained that she doesn't need a frame, and that she can move about if she has some basic support. But did they listen? They insisted she needed a frame, an expensive contraption - the cost of which the NHS has to fork out. And it was only reluctantly that they took it back.

No wonder the NHS is understaffed, the staff are duplicating each other's work like a dog chasing its own tail. And they're giving away costly equipment which patients don't even need.

I don't want to alarm you but if you can't get basic stuff like bandages or a wheel-chair in a hospital, what chances are there of you having something more critical like an operation?

And, would you believe it, a month later (after two phone calls and a letter), there was still no sign of those support bandages...

12 Comments

clifford said:

Birmingham hospital/A&E?

Birmingham surgery?

simon gray said:

Maybe they were just unhelpful to you personally as a result of reading most of what you write here?

Ursula said:

My oh my oh my, Simon, that's a bit below the belt, isn't it?


May I point out that Roshan was taking care of his mother and it was her, not him, who suffered. But then maybe you'd defend a variation of an old biblical saying; in this case, mothers having to suffer for the sins of their sons.


As to the NHS, Roshan, as you know I am looking from the outside in. Anecdotal evidence suggests that there is a lot left to be desired. Yet, my personal experience is the absolute opposite. They spring into action, they refer you, they turn you upside down and put you together again before you can protest that there is nothing wrong with you. Listening to my British friends, most of whom have gone private, and their complaints about the NHS I sometimes wonder if Felix and I get preferential treatment so I won't report anything bad back to the fatherland.


Of course, there is that rather sinister theory that the quality of service is a post code lottery. Who knows. As I keep saying to Felix, and we have spent many a SHORT time in A&E: "Being a patient, patience is the name of the game".


U

clifford said:

Since it is accepted that the level of appropriate care varies across the NHS a post of this nature (which seeks to generalise) is pointless. You need to tell us the name of the hospital and of the surgery.

Roshan Doug said:

Clifford. It was some time ago when City Hospital was called Dudley Road Hospital(what's it called now?)...

simon gray said:

@ursula nothing to do with 'sins of the relatives', more a point that if roshan was relating to the hospital staff the way he gives the impression here of relating to people generally, expressing the kinds of attitudes towards them he expresses here, then is it any wonder people were not going out of their way to be helpful ?

but as it turns out, he's now revealed which hospital it was - dudley road hospital - & he makes the point it was when it was still called that.

it's not been called 'dudley road' hospital for a loooooooooong time - is it getting on for 10 years ago ? so he was relating an anecdote from what is to all intents & purposes ancient history. who knows in that time how far his recollection of the incident has modified to fit his generally negative view of the world ?

Ursula said:

Simon, thank you for your reply to my comment to you. Far be it from me to defend Roshan and his view of the world (and who are we to know what made it so). I am sure he is perfectly capable of fighting his own corner. I myself rarely agree with him - which makes for good discussion, presumably the point of a public blog.


However, one thing I do not understand about the medium of blogging: Why does it come so easy to a lot of people to turn on someone - in writing - when they would never say the same thing to that person's face? I am not British, and most certainly not of the stiff upper lip - if anything the opposite -, but I don't get it. Surely there is a way of conveying displeasure without kicking someone in the shin, says she who is always spoiling for a - verbal - fight.


Let me know.


U

Roshan Doug said:

Thank you, Ursula/Simon - I take your point and will try (try!) and modify by negative world view...

Roshan Doug said:

Thank you, Ursula/Simon - I take your point and will try (try!) and modify by negative world view...

David Bethnam said:

Good evening, Roshan. I've never written to a blogger/writer before but I just wanted to say that I enjoy your pieces. I think the level of criticism directed at you is quite unfair. I have always found your pieces entertaining to read - even when you are 'tongue in cheek', a trait that some of your readers fail to appreciate.

I came across your poetry in the Birmingham Central Library and I must say I was impressed. Your book Delusions is brutally honest though I found some of the poems difficult to get into. Delicate Falling of Gods, however, was very VERY!! poetic. Very evocative.

Your blogs seem to have a light hearted tone and cheekiness - though you've rattled Simon Gray to a rage! But that's what I like - the reaction you get. I love it..keep up the good work.

Roshan Doug said:

Thank you, David. Two comments of support - it must be my lucky day.

A said:

I agree the A&E's aren't the best, but I have to disagree with you on one thing. You say because she is older she isn't receiving the same kind of care as a younger patient. Your right in a way, unlike a young patient she got an Xray RIGHT AWAY! Seriously, if you are older in this country you are taken more seriously, your pain is taken more seriously and you get scans ASAP.

I have to tell you as a young patient, I have to wait a longggggggg time for the same scan, even if I am in worse pain. It doesn't matter because I am in my twenties. So just check some facts before you go on about how older people aren't taken seriously because you couldn't be further from the truth!

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

News authors

Olympic logo

Beijing Blog - Jo Green and Paul Phedon from Birmingham PR firm S&X Media give their account of being at the Beijing Olympics
Postings | Beijing Blog RSS feed Feed

The Big Debate

The Big Debate - Start the debate. Are our Young Leaders our Green Saviours? September 15, Hall 5 the ICC. Postings | The Big Debate RSS feed Feed

Simon Hadley

Simon Hadley - The Birmingham Post's picture editor
My postings | Simon Hadley's RSS feed My feed

Paul Dale

Paul Dale - The Birmingham Post's public affairs editor
My postings | Paul Dale's RSS feed My feed

Phil Davis

Phil Davis - Board member of Passenger Focus (rail transport passenger group)
My postings | Phil Davis's RSS feed My feed

James Treadwell

James Treadwell - Criminologist, Birmingham City University
My postings | James Treadwell's RSS feed My feed

Stef Lewandowski

Stef Lewandowski - Owner of digital design agency 3Form and part of Birmingham's Big City Plan
My postings | Stef Lewandowski's RSS feed My feed

Marc Reeves

Marc Reeves - Editor of The Birmingham Post
My postings | Marc Reeves's RSS feed My feed

Emma Brady

Emma Brady - The Birmingham Post's health correspondent
My postings | Emma Brady's RSS feed My feed

Shahid Naqvi

Shahid Naqvi - The Birmingham Post's education correspondent
My postings | Shahid Naqvi's RSS feed My feed

Jonathan Walker

Jonathan Walker - The Birmingham Post's political editor
My postings | Jonathan Walker's RSS feed My feed

Roshan Doug

Roshan Doug - Writer and political commentator
My postings | Roshan Doug's RSS feed My feed

Joanna Geary

Joanna Geary - Development Editor of The Birmingham Post.
My postings | Joanna Geary's RSS feed My feed

Tom Scotney

Tom Scotney - The Birmingham Post news reporter
My postings | Picture Archive's RSS feed My feed

Latest Birmingham Post Business blog

Latest Birmingham Post Lifestyle blog

Lifestyle Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from the midlands give you the lowdown on what's happening in your region and some musings on culture in the UK and beyond.

Latest Birmingham Post Sport blog

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links