http://blogs.birminghampost.net/news/

Metro extension is Birmingham's dead parrot

By Paul Dale on Nov 27, 08 11:54 AM in

It is difficult in these tumultuous times to be certain about anything.
But one prediction I feel entirely safe in making is this:
The £180 million Midland Metro tram extension through Birmingham city centre, from Snow Hill to Five Ways, will never be built.
At least, not if it has to be paid for by the Government.

This project is as dead as Monty Python's famous Norwegian Blue parrot.
It is no more, it has ceased to be, expired, is bereft of life and must be allowed to rest in peace.
The faintest glimmer of hope for the Metro, that it might be resuscitated as part of the Chancellor's £1 billion transport package to help rescue the economy from recession, disappeared when Alistair Darling failed to include the tram in a number of high-profile projects being brought forward by the Government.
The reason that Mr Darling refused to give the go-ahead for what would be one of the biggest-ever construction projects in Birmingham is clear.
He could not do so because the Department for Transport is unwilling to approve the business case.
Civil servants simply do not believe the tram extension will deliver the cost-benefit returns demanded by the Government.
By the time the figures are refined to the satisfaction of the DfT - if such a thing is possible - it will be too late.
Mr Darling's cash splurge over the next couple of years will be followed by savage public spending cuts.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies estimates £19 billion will be slashed from Whitehall budgets in 2012.
Meanwhile, in Birmingham, the tram really has become the love that dare not speak its name.
Try as we might, journalists still have not been able to draw any backing for the scheme from city council leader Mike Whitby.
Officially, the Snow Hill-Five Ways extension remains a transportation priority.
But Coun Whitby is so lukewarm that he refuses to say whether he would build it in the unlikely event of funding being approved.
Many of his Conservative colleagues, and a number of influential Liberal Democrats, have never been persuaded of the merits of running trams through crowded shopping streets, in particular along Corporation Street and Broad Street. They would far rather encourage private sector investment for a short tram extension from Snow Hill to New Street, in the hope that the line could then be extended further to Eastside and Birmingham Airport.
And if there is any Government money on offer, they believe it should be spent on improving bus services.
And bus supporters will have been encouraged by the latest figures showing a 5.1 million increase in passengers across the West Midlands in the year ended September 2008 - the first time for decades that bus usage has increased.
The only matter of importance remaining to be sorted out is how confirmation that the city centre Metro extension is to be abandoned will be handled by the DfT, passenger transport authority Centro and the city council.
A long period of silence, I predict.

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Metro extension is Birmingham's dead parrot. TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.birminghampost.net/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/96830

2 Comments

Chris said:

Hi Paul - can you try to format your blog posts please? Chances are I might've read this if you had. Is it interesting?

Anthony Millinger said:

I wish that you were wrong, but suspect that you are right. Birmingham is the largest city in the developed world without a modern urban rapid transit network - a fact that the Government chooses to continue to ignore. The DfT and the civil servants to whom you refer are simply being dishonest - they know that the cost-benefit ratio for the metro extensions are excellent, and exceed those for the hugely costly London Crossrail scheme, on which the Government is prepared to spend billions. Birmingham's transport network is increasingly seen as a joke both in this country and abroad. The Government is not interested or remotely ashamed and continues to refuse to support even the most modest proposals to improve our backward and outdated public transport infrastructure. Despite the fact that it will not enable one single additional rail passenger journey, the Government will no doubt use its reluctant and belated support for the long overdue New Street refurbishment as an excuse to ignore the plight of the city's transport for the next decade, as it has for the last. It would be the final insult if the "new" New Street opened without a fully integrated high quality interchange with the still incomplete Metro Line One. Finally, what hope for the much-vaunted Big City Plan if the best prospect for its transport is a few extra buses - a strategy and vision better suited to a small provincial town than to the second city of the world's fifth largest economy. The Government's persistent neglect of our city and region is now nothing short of a scandal. Given Birmingham's strategic importance to the wider regional transport network and beyond, it is a national scandal. Tony Millinger

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human

 

News authors

Birmingham Post Comment

Post Comment - Opinion on the biggest issues of the day.

Postings | Post Comment RSS feedFeed

Marc Reeves

Marc Reeves - Editor of The Birmingham Post
My postings | Marc Reeves's RSS feed My feed

Subscribe to receive updates by email
Paul Dale

Paul Dale - The Birmingham Post's public affairs editor
My postings | Paul Dale's RSS feed My feed Subscribe to receive updates by email

Jonathan Walker

Jonathan Walker - The Birmingham Post's political editor
My postings | Jonathan Walker's RSS feed My feed

Subscribe to receive updates by email
Kate Cooper

Kate Cooper - Runs www.extelligence.org, a website for free-thinking and scientific discussion
My postings | Kate Cooper's RSS feed My feed

Latest Birmingham Post Business blog

Latest Birmingham Post Lifestyle blog

Lifestyle Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from the midlands give you the lowdown on what's happening in your region and some musings on culture in the UK and beyond.

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links