Randal sticks the knife into Mike, with style
Randal Brew's manifesto for the leadership of Birmingham City Council is a stiletto-sharp masterpiece designed to knife Mike Whitby without ever once mentioning him.
The document is called Time for Change - a theme traditonally favoured by those who wish to overthrow established governments.
And true to form, the first few sentences praise Coun Whitby's five-year-old administration for having "much to be proud of".
Failing departments have been turned around, council tax rises kept low and investment has been brought to the city, Brew notes approvingly.
Not much need for change there, then, you might think.
He even takes care to claim, perhaps slightly disingenuously, that "my challenge is not based on a fundamental change of policy".
The rest of the document makes it quite clear that this is exactly what Coun Brew is intent on delivering - plenty of policy changes, fundamental or not.
The first sliver of cold steel comes with the telling phrase that "more needs to be done".
And in a glimpse of what would be a new right wing agenda for Birmingham, Coun Brew promises to get rid of 3,000 council workers in two years.
Assuming that he is referring to the 40,000 non-teaching staff, that's almost 10 per cent of the workforce for the chop.
Quite how this would go down with the Conservatives' Liberal Democrat partners, it is difficult to say. I hazard a guess at not very well at all.
The section on "high cost projects" is remarkable for giving the distinct impression that schemes like the library, Olympic swimming pool and municipal bank are going to be pared back without actually spelling this out in any coherent way.
Coun Brew starts, again, by implying praise for Coun Whitby's vision.
He says: "High cost prestige projects, such as the new library, Olympic swimming pool and the proposed Birmingham Bank are important for the city's image and reputation."
So far so good, but there is a sting in the tail.
He adds: "I would wish to examine the source of their funding and determine priorities in the light of undoubted public sector cutbacks and uncertain support even from the next Conservative government.
"We need to properly assess priorities and affordability so that we are in control of situations rather than reacting to them."
What does this mean? The library project is well underway and towards the end of the planning stage and it is difficult to imagine that a Brew-led council would do any more than tinker around the edges by imposing a bit of cost cutting here and there.
The municipal bank and Olympic pool, however, are surely doomed both in the light of Brew's determination to cut council spending and on the basis of whether these initiatives are really needed in Birmingham.
The real question mark over the manifesto is whether Brew is offering enough to disgruntled backbenchers to secure the votes he needs to topple Whitby.
He promises an "immediate change" by seeking to "engage with backbenchers personally" and to be "more accessible and open to discussion".
Policies should not be presented in a non-negotiable way, as has allegedly happened under the Whitby regime.
He is promising to allow two backbenchers to be elected to the Conservative group executive and to have the body chaired by a backbencher.
And then there is the touchy-feely stuff.
A Randal Brew-led council would be firm but fair, tough but compassionate.
But the new leader wouldn't be a pushover, he would display "steeliness as and when necessary".
Can he win? yes he can.
Will he win? My money remains on Whitby, but much will depend on Monday night's Conservative group meeting where the council leader will have to make the speech of his life in order to save his job.
http://tinyurl.com/oy7bar
Older/Newer
« Tories take expenses transparency to a new level | Whitby confident of winning crucial vote »
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Randal sticks the knife into Mike, with style. TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.birminghampost.net/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/124416









I hold no personal or political brief for either Councillor Whitby or Councillor Brew. However, I find it extraordinary that there is even a leadership contest being held.
At either local or national level, party political leadership contests are usually held after an election. There aren't even elections being held in Birmingham in 2009 so, whatever one's views about Councillor Whitby as Leader, now can surely not be the time to seek to depose him.
To an outsider, this smacks of a power play by those who seek personal advancement under a putative Brew leadership. This is indefensible.
One thing electorates do not like is a divided party. Mr Brew's would be supporters would do well to remember this. Should they - without any form of democratic mandate to claim in their actions - succeed in deposing the existing Council leader they might just find that the Birmingham electorate, and its Conservative voters in particular, prove unforgiving of their nakedly self-serving actions.
Good critique Paul. You make some excellent points.
Quite frankly, I am horrified at the tone of the manifesto, and amazed (but grateful) that Cllr. Brew has actually put this out in the public domain.
It is riddled with inconsistencies. He praises Whitby for his achievements (quite rightly), and proceeds to say he will "build on" this, that, and the other. Yet, as one would expect from a passive "bean counter", he openly talks in brutal fashion about sacking 3000 posts in just two years. As you say, what would the Lib Dems say about this?
What about council housing - the administration's supreme achievement? He says nothing about this. Does he approve of what has been achieved, or are we to deduce that under his leadership that council housing is to be lower down the council's list of priorities?
I think what we will see is Whitby's effervescent leadership style replaced by something austere, miserable, and dare I say it puritanical.
Love him or loathe him, Whitby is a salesman for Brum, he has an enthusiasm (even though at times it could be better channelled) for making Birmingham a 1st class place to live.
Whitby sees Birmingham as an international city, and from his manifesto, Randal Brew sees Birmingham as like Hammersmith & Fulham or any other Tory run London Borough that sees cutting jobs and council tax as a bigger priority than improving people's quality of life.
I don't have a vote in this contest, but if I did, my cross would be put firmly next to Whitby's name.
Roll on Tuesday, when hopefully this embarrassing episode in the recent history of Birmingham Conservatives is brought to a close.
Four more years of Whitby and Birmingham will be on its knees. The council will be bankrupt and Brums Conservatives a national joke. This man has let a catastrophic so called business transformation programme wreck the council, which soon wont be able to deliver basic services. Never has a leader been so unpopular and quite rightly so. Good riddance to bad rubish.
It's about time we heard of some proper tory policies being delivered rather than the higher taxes and grandiose schemes that we've had from this pinko tory council. Good on you Randal! Let's show B'ham what a proper tory council can do: better services and much lower taxes, like in Wandsworth and Westminster.
Longbridge...a Tory you are not.
You've given yourself away! LOL!
Friday night wasn't entirely wasted then?
LOL!
Paul, why has the link to the "manifesto" been taken down?
Weren't you supposed to have received this document?
I for one am glad that you got hold of it, we needed to see what Cllr. Brew had in store for the people of Birmingham.
Well done Paul!