http://blogs.birminghampost.net/news/

Sacking Birmingham social workers a flimsy smokescreen to disguise council's Khyra Ishaq failings

By Paul Dale on Mar 22, 10 12:48 PM in

Birmingham City Council got the favourable publicity it craved by offering a cosy chat to the BBC with Children's Services Director Colin Tucker.
During the course of a half-hour discussion, Mr Tucker let slip that six social workers had been sacked for incompetence during the past year.
The inference, in the course of a discussion about the death of Khyra Ishaq, was obvious enough.
Council social services, under fire for failing Khyra by failing to investigate properly her teachers' concerns that she was being quite literally starved to death by a deranged mother and step-father, was demonstrating that it could be tough when required.

Radio stations were quick to run the story in a way that must have had Terry Brownbill, Birmingham Safeguarding Children Board's £800-a-day spin doctor rubbing his hands in glee. "Birmingham City Council has sacked six social workers following the death of Khyra Ishaq," the bulletins began.
Well, yes, up to a point.
The social workers were all sacked, for showing not the slightest sign that they were up to the job, according to Mr Tucker.
And the dismissals did take place after Khyra's death in May 2008.
But, and here's the cruncher, none of them were ever involved in the Khyra Ishaq case.
Asked about this, a council spokeswoman said: "We never claimed they were involved with Khyra."
That is true, but neither did Mr Tucker go out of his way to make it clear that the case of the six was completely removed from the Khyra Ishaq tragedy. Had he done so, his flimsy smokescreen to disguise the councils' failings over Khyra would have been exposed.
Pertinent questions here might include: how many of the six were qualified social workers, and how many were trainees?
This would put Mr Tucker's claim into some context, for it is not presumably unknown for trainee social workers to be shown the door once managers discover that they are going to make the grade. Firing qualified social workers, however, is a far more serious matter.
The council press office, now so far into its self-dug bunker that it is refusing even to pass on to Mr Tucker journalists' requests for interviews, said it could not find out the division between qualified and trainees.
Another question for Mr Tucker: how many social workers were sacked in 2008, 2007 and 2006?
The fact remains, and this has been confirmed by the council, no one, not a single person, has been sacked or even disciplined over Khyra's gruesome death.
The failure to act is, apparently, because council bosses are waiting for the Safeguarding Board's serious case review before deciding what to do.
But serious case reviews, as we are endlessly told, are "lessons to be learned" reports and do not, heaven forbid, involve apportioning blame.
In that case, then, there can be no point in waiting for the review to be published later in the year, unless of course the council is simply trying to buy time and hoping that the clamour for officials to take responsibility for the appalling and preventable death of a small girl dies down.
Khyra's death will not be forgotten, as long as ink remains in my pen. And to anyone who thinks that sounds a little dramatic, I suggest they read Mrs Justice King's Family Court judgment on care proceedings for Khyra's siblings which lists in full, sickening detail, the failure of social services and education officials.
But be warned, you will need a very strong stomach indeed.

7 Comments

Richard said:

Why don't you set up a confidential phone line for Children's Services whistleblowers since you can't get anywhere through official channels?

uk jobs said:

Great post! I was looking forward and didn’t expect to see it so soon! Again, great, sound advice. Looking forward to read more under those new tabs you added!

Phil said:

Dear Mr. Tucker,
can you tell me why you did not respond to my letter. I also came to the foyer today 26th. As a get-up-and-go operator like yourself I am sure that you could reply in ANY form. I also wish to add a word to my previous letter,
"into the MAW of social service indifference.
I am always available to meet you. But I keep in mind the usual excuses used in the past by other SS units.

Phil said:

As I was saying. Walsall SS. In the spirit of open mindedness. OPEN Government etc.
Could you please tell us of the four charges under which your administration and WITNESS, three children were adopted. You have my address. P. Pilkington or P. Cooper could easily do this. I eagerly wait for a reply.

Phil said:

Would anybody like to know about the missing Court Records and how our FAMILY is paying the price of a sentence that does not EXIST. Would anybody care to know of the callousness with which we have been treated. Well here I am. Let me tell each of you who reads this, if I knew that YOUR FAMILY was in this distress I would speak up for you in the same way.

bloggerlafin said:

methinks dale is a touch miffed that he missed the story!

Robert said:

Michael Gove speaking in BBC News Channel this afternoon Friday 23rd April has said that an incoming Tory gogernment would publish the serious case review into the dreadful Baby P affair.

In the spirit of Conservative open government, why the ongoing silence from Mike Whitby about Khyra Ishaq?

Or is Birmingham's example the true face of Michael Gove's party?

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human

 

News authors

Jonathan Walker

Jonathan Walker - The Birmingham Post's political editor
My postings | Jonathan Walker's RSS feed My feed

Subscribe to receive updates by email
Roshan Doug

Roshan Doug - Poet and freelance journalist
My postings

Alister Scott

Alister Scott - Professor of Spatial Planning and Governance, Birmingham City University
My postings

Recent Posts

Latest Birmingham Post Lifestyle blog

Lifestyle Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from the midlands give you the lowdown on what's happening in your region and some musings on culture in the UK and beyond.

Latest Birmingham Post Science blog

Science Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from Birmingham and the midlands inform and entertain on all science matters.

Latest Birmingham Post Sport blog

News Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from Birmingham and the midlands inform and entertain on all sporting matters.

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links