http://blogs.birminghampost.net/science/

Science reporting in the media

By Russell Beale on Nov 3, 11 07:51 AM in Science

Recently, I've been discussing various aspects of computer science and technology in the media - beyond this blog - and have discussed social media for the tv and local radio stations.

One of the things that I've noticed, and now got used to, is that I'll do a 15 minute interview, with (for tv) chatting and walking and talking and acting out using the computer - and maybe 15 seconds will get shown.

Radio is better - if live, then all is used, whilst for pre-records then maybe half appears. A number of conclusions can be drawn from this, mostly unscientifically.

Either I'm not photogenically good for tv; maybe I have a voice (and a face) for radio; perhaps I don't say that much interesting; maybe media coverage of science is superficial.

If I were wanting to defend my personal construct, I'd perhaps be plumping for the latter, and this would be a tirade against the lack of science in our lives, the shallowness of media, and so on.

However, it isn't going to be that (and nor am I going to argue that I should be seen on tv for my ravishing good looks, either).

It comes down to telling stories.

One of the problems with computer science is that it isn't that good on tv or radio.

You have to interact with it, play with the concepts, explore the software, work through the ideas, before it begins to make sense.

And so it looks odd on tv.

Always, we do set-up shots of me typing on a keyboard, or looking intently at a screen, or using a smartphone - but this doesn't get to the issues.

People are not interested in screens, or typing, or me using a smartphone - instead, they are interested in the consequences and opportunities offered by these technologies and interactions, and hence the human stories underneath.

Maybe this is why science is hard to portray in general media outlets - science is, mostly, about the objective pursuit of understanding and knowledge (and opportunity and creativity and so on, I'd also argue) - but this almost necessarily dispenses with the personal and human element.

As people, we're interested in other people, and when watching the news, we tend to want to understand the human, personal elements as much as the underlying issues. For example, Greek debt is, essentially, meaningless to us: civil servants in Athens losing pensions is less so; maybe not being to go on holiday there next year would be significant.

Famine is commonplace in the world, and we react to it with minor interest; compare that to the public outcry when a specific cat is thrown into a bin by an identifiable person.

Thus, for science to become more mainstream and understood by the public, we need to find stories to tell.

Whether it's done in the intensely personal manner that the current Radio 4 series "The Life Scientific" adopts, in which an individual scientist is interviewed abou their career trajectory (sounds boring, I know, but is fascinating) or in the more thematic manner of technologies used to help in the war, for example (think of all those dambusting series), or in the lively and irreverent approach taken in Discovery's "Mythbusters" in which films, tv and old wives' tales are reproduced to check their validity, it's the story that matters to the public.

And even for Mythbusters, it majors heavily on the presenters' characters too.

At least, that's what the conventional wisdom tells us, and what I've rationalised here. That's what producers produce, and hence that's what we get, so that's what we watch.

However, I do sometimes wonder if there is a place for a different form of scientific media reporting that is interesting and accessible for all. What sort of story would it be telling?

2 Comments

Lis Broome said:

I agree. The general news media doesn't understand science, which is why it sticks to friendly stories that are easy to understand. Keep on trying to raise awareness of science issues to get noticed in the very crowded news agenda. And keep away from any shots of computer screens!

Ian Halstead said:

If TV and radio offer only superficial and unsatisfying coverage, why continue to target them?
There are surely still sufficient options in print and/or online at local, regional and national level.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human

 

Science authors

New Optimists
Kate Cooper

Kate Cooper - New Optimists founder
My postings | Kate Cooper's RSS feed My feed

Russell Beale

Russell Beale - Professor of Human-Computer Interaction, University of Birmingham
My postings | Russel Beale's RSS feed My feed

Roslyn Bill

Roslyn Bill - Reader in Molecular Biosciences & Director of the Aston Research Centre for Healthy Ageing
My postings

Jack Cohen

Jack Cohen - Science of Discworld author, retired reproductive biologist, Hon Prof at the Maths Institute, University of Warwick
My postings

Jon Frampton

Jon Frampton - Director of Research and Professor of Stem Cell Biology, University of Birmingham
My postings

Alison Murray

Alison Murray - Former postdoc biochemist, then TV producer and science writer
My postings

James Tucker

James Tucker - Reader in Supramolecular Chemistry, University of Birmingham
My postings

Kenny Webster

Kenny Webster - Resident Scientist at Thinktank Birmingham
My postings

Craig Jackson

Craig Jackson - Professor of Workplace Health Psychology and Head of the Psychology Dept at BCU
My postings | Craig Jackson's RSS feed My feed

Miriam Gifford

Miriam Gifford - A researcher in plant science in the School of Life Sciences & the Warwick Systems Biology Centre, University of Warwick
My postings

Lucy Harper

Lucy Harper - Communications manager at the Society for Applied Microbiology

Chris Dyke

Chris Dyke - MedilinkWM Director driving collaboration between science and industry to develop innovative healthcare

Latest Birmingham Post Sport blog

News Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from Birmingham and the midlands inform and entertain on all sporting matters.

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links