http://blogs.birminghampost.net/sport/

How bad is bad press for sports men and women?

By Martin Warrillow on May 21, 08 05:45 PM in

I mentioned here in my first contribution that I was curious to find out just who reads The Birmingham Post's sports pages.
It's a topic I expect to develop much further in the coming weeks but after the first few weeks of the season, I'd love to know if Warwickshire's cricketers do.

It's fair to say that the Bears' performances over the first month of the season have been unpredictable. Perhaps the nadir was the first three days of their opening away County Championship match at Northampton.
Warwickshire were simply dreadful - and my colleague George Dobell said so. Never one to shirk from expressing his opinions on the game, our chief cricket writer duly laid into the Bears on the Saturday morning. "Years of poor scouting and coaching and petty squabbles', ' a habit of making the opposition look like world-beaters', 'unless things improve markedly, several will be looking for new clubs or new careers." Ouch.
There was even an obscure Bob Dylan reference that had me, often looked upon in the office as a bit of a walking encyclopedia, trawling fruitlessly through the internet. It did, however, prompt me to write one of those headlines that makes its' author punch the air like West Bromwich Albion's Chris Brunt after driving in a crucial goal: "Bears need a hard rain to fall."
It was supposed to allude to the fact that George had said only a deluge could save Warwickshire from defeat. Well, it didn't rain and the Bears pulled off an outrageous victory, making the fifth-highest fourth-innings total in their illustrious history.
We know, because captain Darren Maddy told The Post, that a team meeting before play on the final morning had inspired his men but I'd be interested to know if George's words had some effect.
Football managers, of course, routinely deny being influenced by what the media write. That's probably largely true and I can only think of one instance involving one of the current big six West Midlands managers where angry telephone calls were exchanged over a story in The Post. The manager involved said his piece, the reporter said theirs and everyone lived happily ever after.
I think professional football players tend to realise that criticism and praise comes packaged with their £20,000 a week, although it's less true of other sports and other areas. Post Rugby Correspondent Brian Dick recently revealed that one player with a West Midlands club hadn't spoken to him for two years after Brian left him out of his team of the year and criticised his conditioning.
I probably overstepped the line much earlier in my career when I quoted a West Midlands non-league football manager as saying a transfer target he had failed to sign wasn't worth the £XXX a week he was making at his current club. That player was playing football as a sideline to his proper job, travelling all over the country at all hours of the week for the love of the game and melted my phone for 30 minutes when he saw the newspaper.
I also criticised another player's workrate and attitude as a particularly bad team went down to another defeat. He didn't speak to me for the remaining 18 months I spent on that newspaper before joining The Post - which was a tad tricky for me, because he was going out with the editor's secretary at the time and for all I know, may now be married to her.
Clubs, however, are a different matter. Professional football clubs claim not to be interested in what the media write and know that the national newspapers sometimes stretch the facts, but if the locals get it wrong, they can be down on us like a ton of bricks.
These days, clubs employ press officers who are often trained journalists and fans at the same time, to promote the party line. Hence the preponderance of 'it's a massive game on Saturday' quotes - the very type of thing I wondered whether Post readers were interested in.

Older/Newer

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: How bad is bad press for sports men and women?.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.birminghampost.net/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/5840

6 Comments

Brian Dick said:

If I can offer my two pennorth I think there’s a time for both quotes and comment-led articles.

Direct quotes give power and authenticity to a piece provided they are interesting in the first place.

Kenny Cunningham’s blast at Steve Bruce a couple of years ago was a wonderful example where the story wrote itself.

However, the trend in modern journalism is to think every utterance, no matter how inane, becomes a story simply because of who has said it. Just look at the way Cristiano Ronaldo’s every word is imbued with such significance.

In handing over column inches to the ramblings of an 22-year-old footballer who has never known anything but life in an institution, a journalist risks their own credibility.

It is my belief that most professional writers can write something in a more interesting way than sportsmen or sportswomen can say it.

In most cases their expertise ends when they return from the rugby field, cricket square or tennis court - at that point they become normal people.

That’s where a good journalist comes in to play, to either extract something interesting from their subject or provide their own insightful analysis.

There’s room for both as long as what ever is produced is coherent and worth reading.

Sid Langley said:

I read George's cricket reports to spot Bob Dylan references. I enjoyed the spectacle of the batsman who fell over himself when running being described as 'a simple twist of feet' and the weather report from the Caribbean 'Blowing in the Windies'

Terence Barry said:

It must be quite an achievement getting Bob Dylan references into cricket reports. Can you give us some more examples please?

Martin Warrillow said:

Now there's a leading suggestion to get this blog going properly. Over to you, dear erudite Post reader - suitable cricket references in Dylan songs please?
Here's some suitable song titles to start you off.
As I Went Out One Morning; Blowing in the Wind (the bails during the Birmingham League matches on Bank Holiday Monday,presumably); Buckets of Rain; Walk Out In The Rain; If You Gotta Go, Go Now (or that throw from extra cover will beat you to the other end).

Terence Barry said:

Nice reply Martin, but how many Dylan references have you or your colleagues managed to sneak past your eagle-eyed bosses. In fact, come to think of it, there must have been times when you hacks have indulged in "in-jokes", included references or messages in your articles that are meaningful only to your partners-in-crime, not the reader. Spill the beans now.

Martin Warrillow said:

Oh, there are numerous examples of in-jokes in our trade, mostly on the production side, although I'm sure my reporting colleagues have sneaked a few past me and our team of eagle-eyed subs, the deep third man of journalism.
However, most of them are useful for pulling out of the bag at any time and it would be more than my life was worth to make them public....wouldn't it, Doug?

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Sport authors

Martin Warrillow

Martin Warrillow - The Birmingham Post's Deputy Sports Editor
My postings | Brian Dick's RSS feed My feed

Brian Dick

Brian Dick - The Birmingham Post's Rugby Correspondent
My postings | Brian Dick's RSS feed My feed

Lisa Smith

Lisa Smith - Sports Reporter for The Birmingham Post
My postings | Lisa Smith's RSS feed My feed

Kym Smith

Kym Smith - Long-suffering Bluenose and football blogger
My postings | Brian Dick's RSS feed My feed

James Peacock

James Peacock - Sports Reporter for The Birmingham Post
My postings | James Peacock's RSS feed My feed

Rob Tanner

Rob Tanner - Sports Reporter for The Birmingham Post
My postings | Rob Tanner's RSS feed My feed

Latest Birmingham Post Lifestyle blog

Lifestyle Blog

Birmingham Post staff and guest bloggers from the midlands give you the lowdown on what's happening in your region and some musings on culture in the UK and beyond.

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links